Geopolitical Battle In Kyrgyzstan Over US Military Lilypond In Central Asia
By K. Gajendra Singh
After the Fall of the Berlin Wall,
a triumphant US led capitalist West went about dismantling the Union of
Socialist Republics and ‘induced’ Moscow’s erstwhile allies in Europe
to join Nato. US & Nato forces , dismembered the multi-ethnic,
multi-religious and multi-lingual Slav and orthodox Yugoslavia
, which with religious and ethnic affinities was strategically closer
to Russia .
Using as pretext the 119 attacks
on US symbols of economic and military might in New York and Washington ,
which more and more people are now coming round to believe was an
inside job or at best allowed to happen like “Pearl Harbour “ which
brought US into WWII ,Washington , instead of attacking Saudi Arabia and
Egypt , from where most of the hijackers originated , first bombed
Afghanistan , coercing ally Pakistan into joining it or get bombed to
stone age and installed a former UNOCOL consultant Hamid Karzai as the
new ruler in Kabul after the Taleban leadership disappeared into
Pakistan and northern Alliance marched into Kabul. Then on flimsy
grounds illegally invaded Iraq in 2003 for its oil.
Taking advantage
of the unraveling of USSR into many states now in utter disarray , under
the pretext of US led ‘War on terror ‘ in Afghanistan
,Washington acquired bases in the heart of central Asia ; in Uzbekistan,
Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan , the last next door to China’s turbulent
Turkic speaking Uighur province of Xinjiang .
Washington then
organized US franchised ( like Mcdonalds ,KFC outlets ) street
revolutions financed by US non governmental fronts and organisations ,
CIA and Washington’s envoys in former Russian allies in Europe and in
Moscow’s near abroad .It succeeded in Serbia ( from which Montenegro was
detached making it landlocked) ,Georgia and Ukraine , but failed in
Belarus .In Uzbekistan , where the regime change was attempted a few
weeks after Kyrgyzstan regime change in March 2005, feisty Islam Karimov
expelled the US forces from its base .
Throughout history ,the former
Soviet Union steppes have been the scene of decisive battles and wars by
chariot riding Indo-Europeans and horse riding Turkish, Mongol and
other tribes who moulded the history of the then known civilized world
in Asia , Middle East , Eastern Europe and Mediterranean. Once again it
occupies a central strategic space , and along with the energy and other
resources of the Middle East , has become an arena of rivalry and for
control.
"Lilypad" concept
of mini-bases for U.S.
forces to leapfrog around the globe.
In the post Berlin
Wall Fall era , fancy schemes were crafted in Pentagon under defense
secretary Donald Rumsfeld , his deputy Paul Wolfowitz and others . In 2004 , still
gloating over its ‘Mission accomplished’ in Iraq ,in ignorance of the
ground realities of an Iraqi resistance on the rise, the Pentagon after
acquiring new bases in former Warsaw pact powers like Bulgaria and
Romania ,as part of America's new "imperial lifeline" wanted an all
comprehensive link to new U.S. bases being built across Central Asia,
Pakistan, Iraq, and the Gulf, designed to cement Washington's hold in
Middle East and Central Asia to exploit its natural resources.
Army heavy tankers and artillery were to be replaced by light,
Canadian-made wheeled armoured vehicles. Troops were trained in
counter-insurgency operations and urban warfare. A "lilypad"
concept of austere, rapidly created skeleton mini-bases would allow U.S. forces to leapfrog around the
globe.
The US armed forces were to be restructured for
"expeditionary warfare" (the British used to call it "the imperial
mission"). This planning process was begun a decade earlier , but
accelerated under the Bush administration, which under the influence of
the military-industry complex has relentlessly militarized US foreign policy. US now spends as much as the rest of world put together
,ostensibly on defense aka defending , strengthening and expanding its
hegemony around the world. The bases in the central Asian republics and
elsewhere were the lillipads for quick transfer of mobile lightly armed
forces to occupy the bases till heavier equipment and larger forces
arrived .
But Manas base in Kyrgyzstan
just outside the capital Bishkek is more than a lilipad .Its strategic
location in the heart of central Asia is a lynchpin in the US armed
forces' movement of troops and supplies in and out of Afghanistan. When the Kyrgyz government threatened to cancel the lease to
the base last summer, the president was wooed with a private letter and
other inducements .Yes the rent on the lease were tripled . But little
benefit from this "strategic relationship" trickles down to the
impoverished people of Kyrgyzstan.
US special envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan Richard Holbrooke in his new
Avatar paid his first visit in February to Kyrgyzstan
, and the three other former Soviet Central Asian republics which
border it, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan , and said ,"35,000 US troops were transiting
each month on their way in and out of Afghanistan." At the rate he mentioned, it adds to 420,000
troops annually. It is no small lilipad ,it is a lilypond. While
US military movements have never been disrupted , movements by troops by
regional countries were hampered .
Another ‘Revolution’ in Kyrgyzstan , now pro-Moscow !
After Kyrgyz President.
Kurmanbek Bakiyev fled the capital Bishkek on 7 April , in the wake of
wide spread violence in which 75 people were killed and 400 wounded Ms. Otunbayeva, a former foreign minister,
announced that she would lead a “people’s government” until a new
constitution could be written and elections held.
Dr Andrea Berg , a
Berlin-based Central Asia researcher with Human Rights Watch commented
recently. "The human rights situation has deteriorated in the last two
to three years, and especially in the last six months. There have been
physical attacks and murders of journalists, closures of newspapers,
trials against high-ranking opposition members. I think the last straw
was the socio-economic problems, increase of the prices for energy, and
on cell phone fees. The US has criticised certain developments in Kyrgyzstan, but in general the main concern was about stability. Human
rights came second."
Ms. Otunbayeva played down
reports that Russia had helped the Opposition to win power after another
senior figure, Omurbek Tekebayev, said that Moscow had “played its
role” in deposing Bakiyev. Tekebayev cited to The Times a series
of critical articles in Russian newspapers which had emboldened the
Opposition and “acted as a signal that Russian authorities would not
support Bakiyev”.
Bakiyev had infuriated Moscow by reneging on a pledge
to close the US base last year after receiving $2.15 billion (£1.4
billion) in Russian loans , even though in the same month, the Kyrgyz parliament voted to end the
U.S. presence. The lease was ultimately renewed with higher rent.
Russia has been the
first country to recognise the new regime amid speculation that it wants
the US airbase closed .Russian prime minister Vladimir Putin
has spoken to Otunbayeva twice since 7 April and offered financial aid
and support. Ms. Otunbayeva had visited Moscow earlier this year in
January and March.
Ms. Otunbayeva has sent a
team led by Almazbek Atambayev, her deputy to Moscow to discuss aid
with Putin to rebuild the country .Officials have accused Bakiyev of
ransacking the state treasury before he fled Bishkek .The frozen banking
system contained only $22 million (£14 million). “The state coffers are
almost empty. All the funds have been transferred,” Edil Baisalov, Ms
Otunbayeva’s chief of staff, said.
Ms
Otunbayeva insisted that she had no plans at present to revise the
agreement on Manas base with Washington, The "the status quo would remain", she said .But who knows , this
could change . The annual rent of about $60 million the US pays
to use the base could be renegotiated. But comments from a Kremlin
official said that “in Kygryzstan, there should be only one base —
Russian”.
According to New York Times
,Washington made its first high-level contact with the interim
government on 10 April and reportedly got assurances that the new
leadership would allow American use of the Manas airport which is so
important in supplies for the war effort in Afghanistan. But a statement
on the State Department Web site did not say exactly how long the US could
count on using the airport.
The agreement was renewed last
June and is due for renewal in July this year . Secretary of state
Hillary Clinton telephoned Ms Otunbayeva in Bishkek and assistant
secretary of state Robert O. Blake sent to Bishkek . Earlier on 10 April
, the United States Embassy in Bishkek issued a statement that stopped
short of endorsing the new government. “We remain a committed partner to
the development of Kyrgyzstan for the benefit of the Kyrgyz people and
intend to continue to support the economic and democratic development of
the country,” it said.
Bakiyev who fled from capital
Bishkek in the north is now holed up in south of the country in his home
town of Jalalabad , in the very heart of Ferghana valley. He was
installed after the overthrow following an organized street violence in
March 2005 named ‘Tulip’ revolution by Western leadership
and media .Then the fall guy was Askar Akayev , who was earlier
promoted as poster boy of democracy by the West .Washington had even
manipulated Kyrgyzstan entry into WTO . A poor country Bishkek was
an unlikely candidate for WTO .
In exchange US had a free run of
Kyrgyz territory adjoining China’s turbulent Turkic speaking Uighur province
of Xinjiang. Kyrgyzstan, a landlocked country of 5 million
impoverished people without oil, is strategically located, sharing its
eastern border with Xinjiang and has Kazakhstan and Russia
in north, Uzbekistan in the west and in south Tajikistan.
US became suspicious in 2005 when the
pliant Akayev , seeing the consolidation and rise of the Russian federation under President Vladimir Putin was taking
steps to come closer to the Kremlin . Ever since 2003 when Akayev
allowed Russia to establish a full-fledged military base in Kant in
Kyrgyzstan “he was not with us –America ‘ .So Washington organized
the Tulip revolution in the wake of earlier successful Rose revolution
in Georgia and Orange revolution in Ukraine and installed as President
Bakiyev. Putin acquiesced , China watched in dismay but it was not a complete
success for Washington either. Akayev fled to his patrons in Moscow.
"The base at Manas will stay as
long as the situation in Afghanistan requires," Kyrgyz Defense Minister Ismail
Isakov said during a news conference with Rumsfeld in July 2005 . "Once
there is stabilization, there will be no need. But now I agree with
[Rumsfeld], who said the situation in Afghanistan is far from
stable." This was Rumsfeld’s second visit to Bishkek that year. Tongue
in cheek he added that independent countries made decisions without any
pressure or outside intervention.
President Bakiyev had thanked
Rumsfeld for the US support and thanked Washington
for its contribution in ensuring that the elections were pronounced
democratic and legal. He said that the US administration was
always with Kyrgyzstan in its democratic and economic development
since its independence. The US reportedly provided $750 million in aid to Kyrgyzstan since its independence in 1991. Claims in the Russian media that
the United States granted $200 million in financial assistance
for continued access to the Manas air base after 2005 regime change,
were denied by Kyrgyz officials
It is not that the
Manas base pumps about $156,000 a day into the local economy and
accounted for about 5% of Kyrgyzstan's GDP but the period of laissez
faire under deposed President Akayev helped infiltrate US friends in to
positions of power in Kyrgyzstan. The country was infested with US
supporters .The training provided to police and military personnel by
USA in Kyrgyzstan and elsewhere is very useful in subverting the loyalty
to wards it .This was a routine Cold War game played by the two super
powers .
While US leaders and captive
corporate media never stop lecturing others on corruption , nepotism and
cronyism , human rights violations , you name it ,Washington has
allowed proxies like Bakiyev Viktor Yushchenko in Ukraine or Georgian
president Mikhail Saakashvili to do the same .The Bakiyev family became
extremely rich following contracts awarded by the
Pentagon ostensibly for providing supplies to the US air base in
Manas .Some estimates put the figure that the Pentagon awarded last year
businesses to members of the Bakiyev family amounting to US$80 million.
(US proxies around the world , knowing their time
is short make hay since somebody is always ready to replace them and
obey US commands . )
Since the days of Akayev , Kyrgyzstan has also allowed US facilities to keep an eye on Xinjiang , via
highly sophisticated electronic devices that could "peep" into Xinjiang
where key Chinese missile sites are located. Since centuries Kyrgyz and
Uighur tribes , specially when pressurized or harassed by Communists in USSR and
China have moved from Kyrgyzstan to Xinjiang and
vice versa . A sizeable Uighur community lives in Kyrgyzstan
and almost 100,000 ethnic Kyrgyz live in Xinjiang. This facilitates
flow of information and organize other activities .Because of extreme
poverty hundreds of Kyrgyz nationals work in Russia
and Kazakhstan.
Strategic moves across Eurasia
After the regime change in Bishkek
in 2005 ,Bakiyev’s Kyrgyz government allowed continued use of its Manas
air base by the US forces. However a few days later following an
attempt to overthrow Karimov in Tashkent ,the Uzbek
government courier delivered a note to the US Embassy in
Tashkent demanding that Washington wind up its Karshi-Khanabad (K2) base
in south Uzbekistan in 180 days. It only increased Manas’s importance
for implementing US policy in the region.
But soon after there was an
announcement of joint Russian Chinese military exercises sending a clear
message to the United States and others. In an unprecedented move China
and Russia carried out joint military exercises from
August 18 to 25 near Russia's far-east port city of Vladivostok, before
moving to the Yellow Sea and then to an area off the coastal Chinese
province of Shandong. Apart from 2000 Russian troops, the exercises
involved Russia's Il-76 transport planes with paratroopers,
Tu-95MS bombers firing cruise missiles at targets in the sea and Su-27SM
fighter jets simulating coverage of ground forces.
On 5 July , 2005 Shanghai
Cooperation Organisation (SCO) sent a notice to USA to set a time table
for withdrawal of its troops from bases in central Asia .These , and
other strategic moves were made on the Eurasian chess board to counter
US led Western intrusion into eastern and even central Eurasian lands ,
by Russia and former Soviet republics along with China. Moscow is
also using regional multilateral organizations, including the SCO and
the CSTO to undermine the American influence and presence in Central Asia.
Russia separated the Collective Security Treaty
Organization (CSTO) from the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS)
into a core group to transform it into a full-fledged collective
security organization. Along with India, Iran and Pakistan have been admitted as Observers to the SCO.
Tulip ‘Revolution’ in Kyrgyzstan
For Washington’s regime change
in Kyrgyzstan in March 2005 after successes in Serbia, Georgia
and Ukraine brought the Great Game right into the heart of
central Asia , see my piece http://www.saag.org/common/uploaded_files/paper1310.html
Briefly ,a wide
spread uprising in Kyrgyzstan was instigated following disputed
parliamentary elections held on February 27 and March 13, 2005 ,first in
Osh in south, bordering Uzbekistan, which then spread to the capital
Bishkek on 24 March in north, forcing President Askar Akayev to flee to
in Moscow.
Opposition leader
Kurmanbek Bakiyev, who led the uprising, was sworn in as Prime Minister
and acting President by the new Parliament on 28 March, after a
compromise with the old Parliament, which gave way to the new one. The
new leaders won support and help from Russian President Vladimir Putin ,
who bided his time .He promised to send emergency aid in food and fuel
which Bishkek desperately needed. The new leadership promised no radical
changes in its foreign policy.
"The coordinates of external
policy will be the same. Russia is our close ally and the central Asians are
brotherly neighbours... (We will) develop our relations with European
countries and the West and first of all with the United States,"
acting Foreign Minister Roza Otunbayeva told reporters. She said that
the new government would stick to agreements with Moscow
and Washington, allowing them to keep their military bases in
the country. Bakiyev said that the U.S. Ambassador Stephen Young was
"one of the first people who came to congratulate me."
For the time being both Moscow
and Washington appeared to have a common goal to preserve
stability in the region, concerned about extremist Islamic groups. The Ferghana
Valley, which the author visited in 1998 is shared by
Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan with a crazy quilt like mix of ethnicities
.It is also considered a hotbed of Islamic fundamentalism. When Afghanistan was under the Taliban, Kyrgyzstan had come under attack in the Ferghana Valley
from militants led by Osama Bin Laden’s associate Juma Namangani, an
ethnic Uzbek. The radical Uzbek Hizb-e Tahrir Hizb ut-Tahrir (Party of
Liberation -based and encouraged by the British – you guessed it , they
are everywhere stoking disruption and divisions ) has cells in southern Kyrgyzstan too.
Then there is the old north-south
divide in Kyrgyzstan .Bakiyev’s stronghold is in
south ,which is predominantly ethnic Uzbek. Kyrgyzstan's
ethnic divide is a problem. Its population is about 65% Kyrgyz with
about 14% ethnic Uzbek. A bigger danger is that the instability may seep
into the Ferghana Valley and affect Uzbekistan too . Osh in
south has traditionally been at odds with Bishkek in the north. A few
sparks from the inter Kyrgyz conflagration in Osh, which has a sizeable
Uzbek minority, with a history of Uzbek-Kyrgyz tensions and rioting,
could ignite Kyrgyz- Uzbek conflict and could even engulf the whole of
the Fergana valley partitioned between Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan and
Tajikistan by Stalin in 1920s with their mixed populations and enclaves,
claims and counter claims. British too left similar divisions behind to
fester in Palestine, India and Cyprus.
Changed
international situation.
Unlike 2005 when US was able to
organize overthrow of Moscow leaning Akayev and install its proxy
Bakiyev ,the international scene has change dramatically and changing
further to Washington’s disadvantage .US armed forces are
caught in the Iraqi quagmire , with its military broken down as
proclaimed in 2006 by former decorated Marine Congressman John Murtha
.The collapsing nature of US economy based on ephemeral and fancy
financial instruments and services lies exposed , with its iconic
institutions like Lehman Brothers and Merryl Lynch collapsing on 15
September, 2008 . Highly indebted ,US economy is accruing even more debt ,with
little signs of real economic recovery .It is being sustained by
artificial stimulus of 3 trillion dollars which exists only on computer
screens .The second shoe of economic decline could fall any time this
year .
US and Israeli
protectorate Georgia encouraged by its masters was given a bloody
bashing by Russia when to test Moscow’s will two years ago , Georgia
tried to recover the disputed south Ossetia , which was transferred to
Tbilisi by Georgia born Marshal Stalin .Apart from south Ossetia ,
Abkhazia was also brought back under Moscow’s control .Since then next
door US ally Azerbaijan , strategically located on the Caspian, is also
becoming cool towards Washington .
A vital blow was
stuck against US led encroachment on Russian strategic space of Ukraine ,
when its President Viktor Yushchenko , installed by US
franchised Orange revolution in 2005 got 5% votes in the
first round of presidential elections early this year .His Orange
revolution partner, the ambitious ,glamorous but erratic Yulia
Tymoshenko was defeated by pro Russian Viktor Yanukovich, who is undoing
the damage in Russian-Ukrainian relations done by his predecessor . See
my http://www.boloji.com/analysis2/0562.html
Recently US's special
representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan , Richard Holbrooke , who used Nato power to
break up Yugoslavia toured the region. He spoke of Al-Qaeda threat
to Central Asia, suggesting that NATO had a role to play in
the region as the only viable security organization .His tour
was followed by the intensive two-day consultations in Bishkek by the
US Central Command chief, David Petraeus. Any US's future strategy in Central Asia now lies in shambles.
What policies the Kyrgyz government would follow will have
repercussions beyond Bishkek .
It could affect U.S. and
NATO plans for the largest military offensive of the Afghan war
scheduled to begin in two months time in Kandahar province.
It could also determine the future of the Collective Security Treaty
Organization and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, the two major
potential barriers to Western military running amuck across the immense
Eurasian space.
After much dillydallying ,Washington finally signed the new
strategic nuclear arms reduction treaty with Russia in Prague. It is
ironical that the regime change in Bishkek took place on the same day
that US President Barack Obama and his Russian counterpart
President Dmitry Medvedev were meeting to sign the first major US-Russia
arms control pact of the post-Cold War era, which is supposed to set in
motion the "reset" of relations between the two countries.
Obama and Medvedev did discuss Kyrgyz regime change
before signing the arms treaty. Michael McFaul, Obama's senior director
for Russian affairs, emphasized that the U.S. did not view the conflict (
in Bishkek ) as any kind of proxy struggle between the U.S. and Russia,
even though Russia previously tried to lay claim to an air base in the
country that the U.S. obtained from the regime now under assault.
“ The people that are allegedly
running Kyrgyzstan ... these are all people we've had contact
with for many years," McFaul said. "This is not some anti-American coup,
that we know for sure. And this is not some
sponsored-by-the-Russians coup, there's just no evidence of that."
U.S. troops working at Manas base outside the capital of Bishkek,
have been restricted to the facility . with humanitarian missions and
other trips temporarily suspended, Manas air field spokesman Maj.
Rickardo Bodden said on 9 April that NATO troops and
supplies flying in and out of Afghanistan and have been cut back.
McFaul claimed that the
cooperation over Kyrgyzstan was another sign of improved U.S.-Russia
relations. He added that there was no specific decision on how the two
nations might respond, though he raised the prospect of a cooperative
measure such a joint statement.
"We're trying to
keep the peace right now. We talked in general terms of things we've got
to coordinate " McFaul said.
Air Force General Duncan McNabb, chief of the U.S.
Transportation Command, said last December that although Manas is "very
essential" to U.S. operations in Afghanistan, "we obviously have other options," While most U.S. troops
arrive in Afghanistan via Manas, only about 20% of their cargo does.
Roughly half travels overland through Pakistan, and the rest comes in from the north via rail
and truck lines, largely through Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. If the U.S. were to lose Manas, U.S. officials would likely
seek a replacement base in the vicinity, exploring options in Azerbaijan, Georgia or
even Uzbekistan.
As part of Obama's plan to send
30,000 more troops into Afghanistan by fall, more than 1,500 U.S. soldiers
cycle through the base every day, either heading into or out of Afghanistan.
Flights between Manas and Afghanistan are aboard Air Force C-17 and other military
aircraft, while those from Manas to Europe use commercial airliners. But beyond that bus
terminal mission, it's also key to lifting supplies into and wounded
troops out of Afghanistan. Air Force KC-135 aerial refueling tankers also
are based at Manas.
But when it comes
to coordinating and guarding their power in UNSC and nuclear hegemony ,
US and Russia with China and UK and France guard an exclusive t club as
can be seen regarding making the UNSC more democratic and
in tune with the realities of 2nd decade of 21st
century and not a an apartheid club of WWII victors and the also ran.
K Gajendra Singh,
Indian ambassador (retired), served as ambassador to Turkey
and Azerbaijan from August 1992 to April 1996. Prior to
that, he served terms as ambassador to Jordan, Romania
and Senegal. He is currently chairman of the Foundation
for Indo-Turkic Studies. Copy right with the author. E-mail: Gajendrak@hotmail.com